Working papers from CausalSmith — econometric theory in which every formal statement, every theorem, assumption, and lemma, is machine-verified in Lean 4. Click any statement in a paper to see the exact Lean code it stands for. The papers build on the Causalean library, which you can browse with natural-language translations and review status.
The main mathematics and Lean formalization are produced by OpenAI's GPT-6.1 Sol, with Anthropic's Claude Opus 5.5 handling planning and Lean code review; the paper write-ups themselves are also drafted by GPT-6.1 Sol.
Most questions the system takes on do not end as a paper. Those are kept as shelved runs, with how far each got and why it stopped.
The verified joint minimax characterization delivers a substantial and carefully positioned theoretical contribution, with remaining revisions concerning sampling language, estimator interpretation, and presentation.
4 findings — 4 minor Read the entire review →
The paper establishes the best possible squared-error rate for estimating the population value of optimal treatment choice across covariate cells and constructs an estimator that attains it. With independent observational data and a known minimum treatment probability , uniformly consistent estimation is possible exactly when the number of cells grows slowly enough that .
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_optvalue_vanishingoverlap_rate_v1,
title = {Estimating optimal treatment value with many covariate cells and shrinking overlap},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-033},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_optvalue_vanishingoverlap_rate_v1/},
note = {Version 4, 2 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 15d86b3}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_optvalue_vanishingoverlap_rate_v1/ Cites version 4 of 2 Oct 2026. We characterize the minimax squared-error risk for estimating the observed optimal treatment value from independent and identically distributed observational data with categorical covariates, binary treatments, and binary outcomes. For sample size , number of covariate cells , and public treatment-overlap floor , the risk is of order with universal comparison constants. The characterization is uniform over unknown cell masses, propensities satisfying the public floor, and conditional outcome means, including treatment-effect ties and null cells. We construct a deterministic observed-data estimator that attains this rate through armwise localization, Jackson polynomial approximation, factorial statistics, and conditional averaging of an auxiliary capped-Poisson construction. The matching lower bound uses weighted approximation and moment-matched probability priors with prescribed common mean, together with a comparison of the full observed likelihood. Consequently, uniform mean-square consistency along growing-cell and shrinking-overlap sequences is possible exactly when . Under consistency and armwise conditional exchangeability, the same risk characterization applies to the causal oracle value.
The AI score (0–10) is a single automated referee's estimate, produced by the pipeline's review stage — it can be inaccurate and is intended only as a rough reference, not a peer-review verdict. Click a score to read the referee's reasoning and its main criticisms. The reader rating (1–5 ★) is the average of star ratings left by signed-in readers, on each paper and on individual statements within it.
The paper delivers a significant and well-positioned sharp minimax-rate result with verified statements, but several exposition and claim-fidelity issues should be cleaned up before publication.
9 findings — 2 major · 5 minor · 2 nit Read the entire review →
For fixed interior overlap 0 < epsilon < 1/2 and d <= rho_epsilon n log n, the paper establishes the sharp minimax MSE rate 1/n + d^2/(n^2 (log n)^2), implying parametric rates up to d = O(sqrt(n) log n) and consistency when d = o(n log n). It also gives an oracle-calibrated comparison near exact randomization and a parametric minimax bracket at the endpoint epsilon = 1/2.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_discrete_ate_minimax_loggap_polynom_054o5w3,
title = {Sharp minimax rates for average treatment effects with discrete confounding under fixed overlap},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-008},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882661},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_discrete_ate_minimax_loggap_polynomial_upper_match/},
note = {Version 2, revised 27 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 8d3b465}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882661 Cites version 2 of 27 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies minimax estimation of the average treatment effect in a finite-alphabet observational model with binary treatment and outcome, unrestricted categorywise nuisance functions, and fixed overlap. For each fixed interior overlap level , there are -dependent constants and a cutoff such that, for every sample size and positive covariate alphabet size , the minimax mean-squared risk over the overlap-restricted iid experiment class is up to constants depending on . Over that same range , , , the upper bound is attained by a computable two-split hybrid estimator with universal numerical tuning: pilot-certified heavy categories are estimated by empirical treatment-control ratios, while pilot-certified light categories are estimated by a Chebyshev reciprocal polynomial whose monomials are lifted by factorial moments. Within the range and , the rate implies a parametric regime and a consistency frontier . The paper also gives an overlap-phase upper envelope: a centered estimator has risk at most for every positive , and at the randomized endpoint the minimax risk is bracketed between and for every positive .
The verified mathematical core delivers a sharp and useful minimax calibration, while the manuscript needs targeted prose repairs for comparison scope, cross-reference hygiene, and a few stale or confusing exposition points.
9 findings — 6 minor · 3 nit Read the entire review →
Under common-probability Bernoulli assignment with fixed interaction order and fixed assignment probability, the paper characterizes the minimax mean squared error for estimating the finite-population all-treated-versus-all-control effect under bounded-degree low-order network interference. The rate is governed by the largest exposed interaction order with nonzero Bernoulli contrast, with matching upper and lower bounds attained by a clipped SNIPE estimator and calibrated block least-favourable priors.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_snipe_degree_frontier_v1,
title = {Minimax mean squared error for low-order network interference under {Bernoulli} assignment},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-009},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882634},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_snipe_degree_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 1a80f96}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882634 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. For fixed interaction order and fixed assignment probability , this paper establishes a finite-population design-based minimax mean squared error frontier, up to constants depending on , for estimating the all-treated-versus-all-control effect under known bounded-degree low-order polynomial interference and common-probability Bernoulli assignment. The constants depend only on and are uniform in , , and ; they may deteriorate as approaches , , or a zero of the Bernoulli contrast. For radius , population size , and degree bound , the paper's coefficient-mass and uniformly bounded-outcome minimax risks share the scale where , the complete-block score energy, is the design second moment of the complete-block score used by the score-weighted neighborhood inverse-probability estimator (SNIPE, the shifted-neighbourhood inverse-probability estimator introduced by CortezRodriguezEichhornYu2023). Equivalently, where , the largest interaction order with nonzero all-one-versus-all-zero Bernoulli contrast, is the exposed order in that contrast. A clipped SNIPE estimator attains the minimax rate on both bounded classes, while unprojected SNIPE attains the linear-regime variance scale. Complete directed -blocks, with active blocks in the block construction of Definition 15, supply the matching lower-bound construction. When , the same blocks give the exact worst-case risk , where is the number of complete blocks, for unprojected SNIPE. The complete-block local linear benchmark is solved exactly for block-local design-unbiased weights on fixed complete directed blocks under the coefficient-mass schedule class, with minimax risk for a population of complete -blocks. For the fair-coin design, even-order Bernoulli contrasts cancel, , and first-order interference yields the frontier .
The paper delivers a substantial, carefully scoped private minimax characterization with honest inference, while several presentation and cross-reference defects require editorial repair.
5 findings — 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
For observational data with a single covariate, this paper establishes matching optimal rates for pure differentially private treatment-effect estimation at a fixed covariate value and intervals with uniform finite-sample 90% coverage, under bounded design density and treatment probabilities, rough propensity and control regressions, and a Lipschitz treatment effect. Both estimation error and honest interval length vanish precisely when sample size times the privacy budget tends to infinity.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_private_cate_roughdesign_frontier_v1,
title = {Private estimation and honest inference for conditional treatment effects with rough nuisance functions},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-028},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_private_cate_roughdesign_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 4, 1 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 2799b3a}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_private_cate_roughdesign_frontier_v1/ Cites version 4 of 1 Oct 2026. We characterize the optimal accuracy of pure differentially private pointwise treatment-effect estimation and honest interval inference from independent binary observational records. The model has a scalar covariate on , an unknown measurable density between and , treatment probabilities between and , propensity and control regressions of Hölder order , and a Lipschitz treatment contrast, all with regularity radius . Within this model, consistency and conditional exchangeability identify the causal contrast almost surely; continuity and positive design density identify its value at the fixed covariate location . For sample size and pure replacement privacy budget , both minimax expected absolute error and minimax maximal expected length of connected intervals with uniform finite-sample coverage have order A count-weighted within-cell pair ratio attains these orders through one joint Laplace release and public tuning. Shared population occupancy weights accommodate every admissible design density. Causal testing alternatives supply matching lower bounds for the respective private decision problems. Along admissible privacy-budget sequences, vanishing optimal risk and honest expected length are equivalent to .
For a partially observed system with binary observed states, hidden states, and actions, the paper establishes that the best achievable mean-squared error for stationary policy evaluation scales as the inverse of trajectory length. This rate holds under known policies, bounded rewards, and fixed bounds on mixing and action likelihood ratios.
We characterize the minimax mean-squared error for stationary policy evaluation from one stationary behavior trajectory in a partially observed Markov decision process with binary observed states, binary hidden states, and binary actions. The behavior and target policies are known, actions are randomized conditional on the observed state, rewards lie in , action likelihood ratios are bounded, and both policy-induced joint-state kernels satisfy a common strict total-variation contraction bound. At fixed mixing and action-overlap parameters, the minimax risk has order , where is the observed trajectory length. Seven action-weighted reward moments identify the stationary reward of a contracting four-state scalar realization, and that reward is uniformly Lipschitz in those moments, including across reduced-rank realizations. A finite stable-grid estimator attains the upper bound, and a coincident-policy four-state testing pair supplies the matching lower bound. The same order holds in the binary class restricted by any fixed target-to-behavior stationary occupancy-ratio bound greater than one. This characterization distinguishes the fixed binary experiment from stationary evaluation classes whose hidden-state cardinality grows with trajectory length.
The verified results deliver a meaningful and carefully scoped theoretical contribution, with revisions needed chiefly for exposition, attribution, and interpretation of the calibration.
8 findings — 7 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
Under fixed overlap and valid, monotone instruments whose conditional complier shares and weighted effects transport to the target population, the paper establishes the optimal length of uniformly honest confidence intervals with rough nuisance functions. One observable interval procedure attains this length across all compliance-strength floors: intervals have constant-order length for weak compliance and shrink at rate for stronger compliance, where is the transported first-stage floor.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_transport_cace_roughnuisance_length_v1,
title = {Honest confidence intervals for transported complier effects with rough nuisance functions},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-030},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_transport_cace_roughnuisance_length_v1/},
note = {Version 3, 1 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 46d0720}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_transport_cace_roughnuisance_length_v1/ Cites version 3 of 1 Oct 2026. We characterize the optimal expected length of uniformly honest confidence intervals for a target-population complier average treatment effect in an equal-size two-sample experiment. The data comprise independent source records containing a scalar covariate, encouragement, treatment receipt and outcome, together with independent target covariate records. Source and target densities, the encouragement propensity and conditional arm means are unknown and belong to fixed Hölder classes with exponent . For , under fixed density envelopes, encouragement overlap, bounded potential outcomes, instrument validity, monotonicity, and transport of conditional complier shares and complier-weighted outcome effects, the minimax expected length is of order , uniformly over , where is the transported first-stage evaluation floor. Coverage is required over the full model with positive transported compliance. An observable split-sample cubic estimator and calibrated affine-score inversion attain this order with a single interval sequence across all floors. A matching lower bound uses a continuum of admissible instrumental-variable laws with a no-defiers potential-outcome realization and applies to arbitrary measurable confidence sets. The frontier has a constant-order branch when the strength floor is at or below the rough estimation scale and an inverse-strength branch above it.
The verified characterization makes a substantial theoretical contribution with careful scope control, but extensive repetition and formal bookkeeping require substantial editorial restructuring for journal publication.
5 findings — 1 major · 3 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
Under a known uniform covariate design, fixed treatment overlap, and the stated causal and smoothness assumptions, we establish the best possible estimation precision for a conditional treatment effect using labeled and outcome-free records. The sharp rate identifies exactly when adding outcome-free records improves precision and how many labels and total treatment records are needed for a target error level.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_twosample_pointcate_annotation_frontier_v1,
title = {Outcome-free records and the minimax precision of conditional treatment effect estimation},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-035},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_twosample_pointcate_annotation_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 7, revised 4 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 44d8edc}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_twosample_pointcate_annotation_frontier_v1/ Cites version 7 of 4 Oct 2026. We characterize the value of outcome-free covariate-treatment records for estimating a conditional average treatment effect at the center of the unit covariate cube. The experiment combines independent labeled and outcome-free samples from a common population. Under a known uniform covariate design, conditional exchangeability, a public overlap level with propensity values in , binary responses with arm means in , and public Hölder regularity, we establish the sharp minimax expected absolute-error rate uniformly over labeled counts of at least two and every nonnegative auxiliary count. The propensity and control-mean smoothness orders lie in , the contrast smoothness order lies in , and the common public Hölder radius satisfies . The rate is the maximum of a labeled-sample term and a term involving the product of labeled and total treatment-record counts. A guarded local polynomial estimator with a rectangular projection correction attains this rate. The matching lower bound combines fixed-size mixtures of the original records, which govern the product-of-counts regime, with a two-hypothesis bound under a supplied propensity, which gives the labeled-sample floor. The characterization yields necessary and sufficient sample-growth conditions for attaining the supplied-propensity order and for improving strictly over labeled records alone. It also gives simultaneous acquisition requirements on response labels and total treatment records for a target error scale. The rate exponents do not depend on , while the comparison constants may depend on it together with the other fixed public parameters.
The verified matched rate is a substantial contribution, but the central statistical mechanism needs a clearer explanation before the paper is ready for a leading journal.
6 findings — 1 major · 5 minor Read the entire review →
Under independent sampling, conditional exchangeability, and fixed treatment overlap, the paper establishes the finite-sample minimax rate for estimating the entire budgeted treatment-value curve on any budget interval symmetric about half capacity. A specified estimator attains the rate , including when budgets range from zero to full capacity.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_discrete_budgetvalue_curve_v1,
title = {Minimax estimation of budgeted treatment value curves with discrete covariates},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-024},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_discrete_budgetvalue_curve_v1/},
note = {Version 4, 29 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit c4f4de3}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_discrete_budgetvalue_curve_v1/ Cites version 4 of 29 Sep 2026. We study the population oracle-value curve indexed by treatment capacity for a binary treatment and outcome on a known discrete covariate alphabet. Under independent sampling, consistency built into the observation map, conditional exchangeability, and fixed treatment overlap, we characterize the finite-sample minimax risk for estimating the curve over any closed interval of budgets symmetric about one half. For every sample size , alphabet size , and interval endpoint , the all-procedure expected squared supremum risk on is of order , with constants depending only on overlap. A specified Jackson–factorial estimator attains the upper bound by estimating one shadow-price process and then recovering the entire curve through a dual minimum. A matching lower bound holds at half capacity within a family whose occupied-cell treatment effects are positive, whose capacity binds, and whose full-capacity value is fixed. The result includes simultaneous estimation over every budget from zero to full capacity at the same minimax rate as the unrestricted full-capacity scalar value.
The verified results establish a substantial exact efficiency characterization, while computational reproducibility, economical exposition, and evidence supporting practical trial use require substantial development.
6 findings — 2 major · 4 minor Read the entire review →
Given a measurable strong-saddle selector, the paper establishes the exact asymptotic accuracy bound for estimating average treatment effects in randomized trials with binary outcomes under local differential privacy. A private-pilot estimator attains this bound within the regular class and provides consistent variance estimates and pointwise asymptotically valid confidence intervals.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_ldp_ate_efficiency_surface_v1,
title = {Efficient estimation of binary treatment effects under local differential privacy},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-031},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_ldp_ate_efficiency_surface_v1/},
note = {Version 3, revised 2 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit f9001b6}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_ldp_ate_efficiency_surface_v1/ Cites version 3 of 2 Oct 2026. We characterize the exact regular local asymptotic minimax squared-error bound for estimating the average treatment effect in an independently sampled randomized trial with binary outcomes, known interior assignment probability, interior arm means, and a fixed positive local privacy budget. Each subject releases one privatized assignment–outcome record, and release rules may adapt to earlier outputs on arbitrary measurable spaces. The optimal stationary contrast variance is the reciprocal of a finite, fourteen-pattern staircase saddle that profiles out the common-mean nuisance direction, and it lower-bounds local asymptotic minimax squared-error risk for every sequential private procedure. The attainment results assume a fixed measurable strong-saddle selector satisfying the stated conditions. Fixing any such selector, a private-pilot affine estimator attains the bound within the regular class and supplies consistent variance estimation and pointwise asymptotically valid Wald intervals, including at optimal-support changes. An attaining stationary release always exists with at most five active outputs; certified open neighborhoods have exact minimum cardinalities of five and three. Balanced assignment and complementary arm means yield an optimal binary randomized-response release. A comparison with the published known-assignment custom-Laplace sample mean translates the variance improvement at a specified balanced design point into prospective interval-length and recruitment calculations.
The verified contribution is substantial and generally represented faithfully, but extensive repetition and an underdeveloped econometric motivation require substantial editorial revision.
5 findings — 1 major · 4 minor Read the entire review →
Under a global restriction on how often treatment probabilities become small and known response smoothness, the paper establishes the optimal rate for recovering the treated causal response at a point and in expected worst-case error across the covariate domain. A local-polynomial estimator attains this rate by choosing its mesh from treated observation counts, uniformly over fixed compact ranges of overlap exponents above one.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_weakoverlap_unisolvent_rate_v1,
title = {Minimax response recovery under global overlap tails},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-026},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_weakoverlap_unisolvent_rate_v1/},
note = {Version 3, 1 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit d07574d}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_weakoverlap_unisolvent_rate_v1/ Cites version 3 of 1 Oct 2026. We characterize minimax recovery of the treated causal response under a global propensity-tail restriction. The model combines consistency and conditional exchangeability with a covariate density bounded below on a cube, intrinsic Hölder response smoothness of known order , a bounded treated conditional mean, and uniformly conditional sub-Gaussian residuals. If is the covariate dimension, is the sample size, and is the overlap exponent, the pointwise and expected spatial-supremum minimax risks have scale An explicit estimator fits local polynomials with equal aggregate weight across fixed template microcells and selects its mesh through treated observation counts. With model constants fixed, its expected spatial-supremum guarantee attains this pure-power rate uniformly over fixed compact overlap intervals with distinct endpoints in , using the known smoothness and observed treatment design. A bounded, two-valued potential-outcome experiment supplies the matching pointwise lower bound at every fixed point of the closed cube. In dimensions at least two, a thin-strip construction exhibits admissible treatment geometry with degenerating local treated variation. An affine transfer also establishes the expected spatial-supremum upper guarantee for fixed-constant Gaussian source envelopes satisfying Dorn's retained moment, variance, smoothness, uniform-design, and global-tail restrictions.
The paper delivers a significant matched minimax characterization with a carefully specified estimator, but central verification claims and artifact metadata require correction before publication.
8 findings — 2 major · 6 minor Read the entire review →
The paper establishes that the finite-sample minimax squared risk for estimating the optimal-treatment value is of order , attained by an explicit estimator. This characterization applies to binary treatments and outcomes with discrete covariate values under consistency, conditional exchangeability, i.i.d. sampling, and fixed overlap.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_discrete_optimal_value_minimax_matc_068dybx,
title = {Minimax estimation of optimal treatment values with discrete covariates},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-015},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882663},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_discrete_optimal_value_minimax_matched_jackson_factorial/},
note = {Version 2, revised 12 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit d4751b9}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882663 Cites version 2 of 12 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper characterizes the finite-sample minimax risk for estimating the scalar optimal-treatment value with a binary treatment, binary outcome, and a discrete covariate alphabet of size . Under consistency, conditional exchangeability, i.i.d. observed sampling, and a fixed overlap parameter , the causal value equals the observed-law functional that sums, over covariate cells, the larger of the two arm-specific outcome regressions. For sample size , the fixed-sample minimax squared risk satisfies The upper bound is attained by an explicit Jackson factorial estimator: pilot counts form local rectangles for each four-coordinate treatment–outcome cell table, a tensor Jackson polynomial approximates the cellwise maximum contribution, centered factorial moments lift the polynomial into unbiased count statistics under Poisson splitting, and Rao–Blackwellization returns an all-data fixed-sample estimator. The lower bound embeds normalized two-sample distance into an equal-propensity slice of the observed model and uses moment matching for the absolute-value cusp. The matched rate gives uniform consistency exactly when and gives the parametric minimax scale exactly along bounded-alphabet sequences.
The paper delivers a significant sharp minimax result with faithful formal statements, but its publication case is weakened by an unstated load-bearing lower-bound input, proof-led organization, and several misleading presentation choices.
9 findings — 2 major · 6 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
Under fixed overlap in a finite-alphabet causal experiment, the paper characterizes the minimax mean-squared risk for estimating the average treatment effect when outcome-labeled records are augmented by treatment-covariate records. The rate separates labeled outcome information from treatment-covariate marginal information, yielding for the unrestricted cellwise model.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_semisupervised_discrete_ate_annotat_0o7smr7,
title = {Outcome annotation and minimax risk for discrete average treatment effects},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-022},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882683},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_semisupervised_discrete_ate_annotation_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 20 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit db544e5}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882683 Cites version 2 of 20 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper characterizes the minimax value of outcome annotation in a finite-alphabet causal experiment. A sample of complete records is augmented by additional records from the same population, where takes known values, and are binary, and occupied covariate cells satisfy overlap at level . For the average treatment effect under consistency and conditional exchangeability, the minimax mean-squared risk satisfies, uniformly over the unrestricted cellwise model, The rate separates outcome information from treatment–covariate marginal information: the term is the labeled-outcome contribution, while the alphabet-dependent term is governed by the combined treatment–covariate records. The upper bound is attained by a fully specified hybrid estimator that uses polynomial correction in light cells and stabilized inverse counts in heavy cells. The lower bound uses common-marginal priors whose induced treatment–covariate tables have the same distribution across hypotheses, so the auxiliary sample is aligned with the marginal-information component. The characterization yields exact consistency, parametric-rate, strict-improvement, binary-alphabet, inverse-count-baseline, and known-marginal-limit consequences for the annotation experiment.
The verified identification and rate results are substantial, but the closest methodological comparisons and the definition of the proposed external-log interval need work before publication.
6 findings — 2 major · 4 minor Read the entire review →
For randomized trials that release outcomes linked to assignment-probability labels rather than individual probabilities, the paper characterizes the sharp worst-case uncertainty in the average treatment effect and shows how to design labels and confidence intervals. Under bounded outcomes and fixed overlap, using labels reduces worst-case ambiguity at rate .
@techreport{causalsmith_pid_unlinked_propensity_ate_v1,
title = {Assignment probabilities without row-level links: {Identification}, label design, and inference in randomized trials},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-023},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/pid_unlinked_propensity_ate_v1/},
note = {Version 5, 29 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 9135ac1}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/pid_unlinked_propensity_ate_v1/ Cites version 5 of 29 Sep 2026. We study a randomized trial in which treatment and outcome remain linked to a deterministic label of the assignment probability. The population score distribution is known in the identification and design experiments and sampled independently in the external-log experiment. Under bounded outcomes and fixed uniform overlap, we characterize the maximum width of the sharp average treatment effect interval across compatible released outcome laws for any measurable finite-label rule. Its exact cellwise expression is attained by a released law with Bernoulli one-half outcomes in every positive-mass arm-label cell, including for atomic score distributions and disconnected cells. Universal point identification holds precisely when the label determines the assignment probability almost surely. With a budget of labels, optimal worst-case ambiguity has order over score laws with a common positive density lower bound; an equal-width construction gives the upper bound for every score law. For continuous, strictly positive score densities, we derive the exact high-resolution constant and an asymptotically attaining interval-cell allocation. For trial size and a known score law, the minimax expected length of a uniformly honest interval has order over the lower-density class. With a fixed release and an independent score log of size , a projection interval attains excess-length order ; separate lower bounds establish both sampling directions at a fixed positive trial-to-log size ratio.
The verified uniform frontier is a substantial theoretical contribution, while publication readiness requires sharper comparative positioning, an operational assessment of the finite-sample certificate, and a more economical presentation.
8 findings — 2 major · 5 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
When treatment records which side of the true cutoff a person falls on, the paper establishes matching optimal rates for estimating the cutoff effect and constructing honest confidence intervals under independent Gaussian measurement error. For the stated compact-support Hölder class with known noise level, these rates cover the full transition from an accurately measured score to fixed positive noise, and explicit procedures attain them with finite-sample coverage.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_rd_trueside_noise_frontier_v1,
title = {Uniform estimation and honest inference in regression discontinuity with a mismeasured score},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-029},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_rd_trueside_noise_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 5, 1 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit f9001b6}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_rd_trueside_noise_frontier_v1/ Cites version 5 of 1 Oct 2026. We characterize minimax estimation and honest inference for a latent-cutoff treatment effect when treatment records the true cutoff side and the running variable is measured with independent Gaussian error. The benchmark has known latent support , a continuous score density bounded between and , and binary potential outcomes whose continuous conditional means lie between the same bounds and have full-interval Hölder seminorm at most two. For each fixed Hölder exponent , minimax expected absolute error and minimax expected length of connected intervals with uniform coverage have a common rate, uniformly over sample sizes and known noise standard deviations . A scalar resolution equation characterizes this rate across direct, intermediate, and compact-support regimes, including their interfaces. The direct rate is . For each fixed positive noise level, the asymptotic rate as is , with comparison constants permitted to depend on that fixed noise level. Observable inverse-heat polynomial ratios and deterministic selection by a public radius attain the frontier with finite-sample coverage. Matching lower bounds apply to all measurable procedures, including independently randomized procedures. A target- and experiment-preserving embedding also transfers the benchmark lower bounds to a larger locally regular Gaussian class.
The verified overlap-uniform frontier offers a credible theoretical contribution, but the manuscript needs substantial reorganization and several concrete presentation corrections to communicate it effectively.
5 findings — 1 major · 3 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
For binary treatment and outcomes with finitely many covariate categories, the paper establishes the best achievable squared-error accuracy for a population-weighted treatment contrast as treatment overlap diminishes. Under a known lower bound on treatment probabilities, auxiliary treatment–covariate records improve precision toward the benchmark with known covariate proportions.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_annotation_rarearm_frontier_v1,
title = {Treatment effect estimation with auxiliary records and diminishing overlap},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-037},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_annotation_rarearm_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 9, 3 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 70df51f}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_annotation_rarearm_frontier_v1/ Cites version 9 of 3 Oct 2026. We characterize minimax squared-error precision for a population-weighted treatment contrast with binary treatment and outcomes and finite discrete covariates. The experiment supplies independent samples from a common population: complete records containing outcomes, treatment, and covariates, and auxiliary treatment–covariate records. Covariates have categories, and treatment propensities in occupied cells lie in , where is a public overlap floor. Over arbitrary covariate probabilities and cellwise outcome means, the minimax risk is with numerical comparison constants independent of all four indices. A deterministic estimator on the original records attains this order with proof-oriented tuning and numerical constants, and a matching lower bound applies to all Borel randomized rules on those records. The comparison yields exact sequence criteria for consistency, for joint consistency and rare-label benchmark attainment, and for a vanishing risk ratio relative to complete records alone. At fixed complete-record size, alphabet size, and overlap floor, increasing auxiliary information converges to the exact-marginal minimax benchmark. Under potential-outcome consistency and conditional treatment exchangeability, the contrast equals the population average treatment effect.
The verified all-radius characterization provides a substantial theoretical contribution with faithful scope, while the manuscript requires major organizational revision and several targeted exposition and attribution repairs.
5 findings — 1 major · 4 minor Read the entire review →
Under the stated bounded logistic model with a known uniform scalar covariate and low prognosis smoothness, we establish the sharp expected length of uniformly valid confidence intervals for a homogeneous causal log-odds effect. A single interval achieves this optimal length across all effect-size evaluation radii with finite-sample 90% coverage, revealing how effect magnitude scales the contribution of prognosis uncertainty.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_logodds_lowsmooth_frontier_v1,
title = {Honest confidence intervals for homogeneous causal log odds under low smoothness},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-038},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_logodds_lowsmooth_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 3, 3 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 1efc342}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_logodds_lowsmooth_frontier_v1/ Cites version 3 of 3 Oct 2026. We characterize the sharp expected length of honest confidence intervals for a homogeneous conditional log-odds coefficient with binary treatment and outcome. The experiment has a known uniform scalar covariate design, an effect bounded in absolute value by , and propensity and control-risk logits with supremum norms at most and Hölder seminorms at most . For public propensity and prognosis smoothness exponents satisfying and , coverage is required uniformly over this ambient model, while expected length is evaluated on laws with effect magnitude at most , the evaluation radius. For every sample size and , the minimax expected length is, up to absolute constants, One radius-independent interval attains this profile simultaneously across all radii with finite-sample coverage. Separate projection estimates and joint inversion yield rational endpoints at prescribed rank and endpoint precision levels, using public finite-recurrence bounds for the primitive arithmetic on valid represented inputs. Continuous calibrated alternatives within the same homogeneous logistic model establish matching lower bounds, including for randomized procedures. The characterization explains how effect magnitude scales the contribution of prognosis uncertainty and identifies the balance between that contribution and the uncertainty remaining at zero effect.
The verified uniform frontier is a substantial theoretical contribution, while publication requires a more focused exposition, numerical assessment of the explicit procedure, and sharper attribution of methodological antecedents.
7 findings — 2 major · 5 minor Read the entire review →
Under fixed smoothness and polynomially vanishing dose support, the paper establishes matching optimal orders for estimating the causal mean at a prespecified latent dose and for the length of honest confidence intervals with known Gaussian measurement error. It characterizes how these orders change with the error scale and constructs an observable estimator with an interval that guarantees finite-sample coverage throughout the model class.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_noisydose_weakdesign_transition_v1,
title = {Pointwise causal estimation with weak dose support and {Gaussian} measurement error},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-032},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_noisydose_weakdesign_transition_v1/},
note = {Version 11, revised 5 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 44d8edc}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_noisydose_weakdesign_transition_v1/ Cites version 11 of 5 Oct 2026. Under calibrated public density envelopes satisfying , where and are the density-envelope constants and is the design-decay exponent, we characterize optimal estimation and honest interval length for the population causal mean at a prespecified latent dose when treatment is measured with Gaussian error and local dose support may vanish polynomially. The model has two observed strata, compact latent-dose support, bounded potential outcomes, schedule-level conditional exchangeability, and classical measurement error with known standard deviation . Conditional mean functions have Hölder exponent , and conditional dose densities satisfy these public polynomial envelopes with . For this calibrated class and any fixed noncoverage probability , minimax expected absolute error and minimum worst-law expected length of honest connected -coverage intervals have matching orders, uniformly over the error scale. For sample size , the characterization combines a direct weak-design regime with rate , an intermediate Gaussian-inversion regime, and a compact-support regime. Neighboring rate formulas are comparable throughout fixed multiplicative neighborhoods of both transition thresholds. Every fixed error scale yields order for this calibrated class. An observable estimator selects among Fourier, polynomial, and constant inverse weights using public error certificates, with the declared small-sample fallback; its associated interval has finite-sample coverage for every . Under the same envelope calibration, matching lower bounds follow from bounded Bernoulli structural alternatives whose causal means are separated while their complete observed samples remain difficult to distinguish.
The verified precision characterization is substantial and its headline claims are faithful, but extensive duplication and an underdeveloped explanation of the information mechanism require a substantial editorial revision.
5 findings — 1 major · 4 minor Read the entire review →
Under independent half-probability treatment assignment, independent edge retention with known probability , noiseless outcomes, and bounded additive effects, the paper establishes that the best achievable squared-error precision for the total treatment effect is of order , where is population size and bounds incoming and outgoing network connections. Retaining edges at a rate of order or greater achieves the same precision order as observing the full network.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_thinnedgraph_additive_risk_frontier_v1,
title = {Minimax precision for total treatment effects with partially observed interference networks},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-039},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_thinnedgraph_additive_risk_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 3, 3 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 1efc342}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_thinnedgraph_additive_risk_frontier_v1/ Cites version 3 of 3 Oct 2026. We characterize minimax squared-error precision for the population all-treated-versus-all-control contrast under heterogeneous additive interference and sampled network information. The experiment assigns treatment independently with probability one half, retains each true directed off-diagonal arrow independently with known probability , the edge-retention probability, and observes the retained graph, every assignment, and every noiseless realized outcome. Fixed schedules have population size , common in- and out-degree bound , and absolute coefficient mass at most one for each outcome, including its baseline and own-treatment coefficients. Uniformly over integers and , and retention probabilities , minimax squared risk is of order with universal comparison constants; at zero retention it is of constant order. A clipped-or-zero inverse-inclusion rule attains this scale, and the converse covers every measurable randomized estimator using the complete observed record. For degree sequences and retention sequences , uniform consistency is possible exactly when and , interpreting the second ratio as infinite at zero retention. Retention of order or greater attains the supplied-graph precision order. These results connect calibrated edge collection to attainable total-effect precision under the stated assignment and sampling design.
The verified arrival-and-dimension characterization is a substantial theoretical contribution, but publication requires a clearer statistical narrative, substantial compression, and a correction to the description of the converse construction.
5 findings — 2 major · 3 minor Read the entire review →
For balanced randomized experiments with binary outcomes missing at random given baseline, treatment, and a binary surrogate, the paper establishes the optimal estimation error and honest confidence interval length for the population average treatment effect. Under a known cellwise outcome-arrival floor of at least one-half, it constructs procedures attaining these bounds uniformly across baseline distributions, with precision depending on sample size, the number of baseline categories, and the arrival floor.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_mar_nearcomplete_frontier_v1,
title = {Minimax estimation and honest inference in randomized experiments with missing outcomes},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-027},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_mar_nearcomplete_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 3, 1 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit d07574d}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_mar_nearcomplete_frontier_v1/ Cites version 3 of 1 Oct 2026. We characterize optimal estimation and honest inference for the population average treatment effect in a balanced randomized experiment with incomplete primary outcomes. Each record retains a baseline category, treatment, a binary surrogate, outcome-arrival status, and the observed binary outcome mark. Outcome arrival is missing at random conditional on baseline, treatment, and surrogate, with a known cellwise arrival floor . For sample size and at most baseline categories, the minimax squared-error risk is, up to universal constants, For each fixed noncoverage level , the minimax worst-law expected length of honest connected confidence intervals has the square-root order of this benchmark. A polynomial-and-ratio correction weighted by missing-outcome cell membership attains the estimation bound, and a clipped risk-based interval attains the length bound. Matching lower bounds use exactly normalized causal priors with close complete observed-sample mixtures and separated treatment effects. The characterization is uniform over arbitrary baseline masses and admissible cellwise arrival probabilities and outcome means, and yields dimension-independent parametric precision at complete arrival.
The verified characterization provides a substantial theoretical contribution with largely faithful scope, while extensive repetition and insufficiently developed econometric interpretation require substantial revision for publication.
7 findings — 1 major · 6 minor Read the entire review →
Under independent uniform covariates and a pooled Sobolev smoothness budget for centered main and pairwise effects, the paper establishes the finite-sample minimax excess variance of Horvitz–Thompson estimation: its scaled value is comparable to . A single fair, outcome-independent assignment rule attains this rate without knowing smoothness, with excess variance vanishing exactly when for fixed smoothness.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_bivariate_sobolev_design_capacity_v1,
title = {Minimax excess variance with smooth pairwise interactions in randomized experiments},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-040},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_bivariate_sobolev_design_capacity_v1/},
note = {Version 3, revised 4 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 1efc342}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_bivariate_sobolev_design_capacity_v1/ Cites version 3 of 4 Oct 2026. We characterize the finite-sample minimax excess variance of Horvitz–Thompson estimation under covariate-dependent experimental assignment. Covariates are independent uniform draws on the unit cube, and the conditional potential-outcome midpoint mean is centered, has an exact main-and-pair-effect decomposition, and satisfies a pooled nonperiodic Sobolev restriction-norm budget. For every sample size , covariate dimension , and smoothness , the minimax scaled excess variance is comparable to , where is the number of coordinate pairs, with positive comparison constants uniform over this parameter range. A single fair, outcome-independent assignment law, independent of smoothness, attains this scale on all original units. An independent coefficient-sign prior supplies the matching lower bound against every admissible design. The characterization is logarithm-free, includes the endpoint , and yields vanishing minimax scaled excess exactly when for each fixed smoothness. The causal interpretation applies to arbitrary square-integrable potential outcomes with the specified uniform-covariate prognostic class.
The verified characterization is a substantial theoretical contribution with careful scope control, but extensive repetition, disrupted ordering, and several concrete presentation errors require substantial editorial revision.
6 findings — 1 major · 5 minor Read the entire review →
Conditional on the classical Bernstein limit for polynomial approximation, the paper establishes optimal estimation accuracy and honest confidence-interval length for first-best treatment welfare in randomized binary trials under one-message local privacy, including exact treatment ties. An explicit noninteractive procedure attains these limits, which also apply to sequentially interactive procedures.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_ldp_optvalue_uniform_frontier_v1,
title = {Optimal treatment welfare under local privacy: {Minimax} estimation and honest inference},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-036},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_ldp_optvalue_uniform_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 3, 3 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 3a4c7a8}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_ldp_optvalue_uniform_frontier_v1/ Cites version 3 of 3 Oct 2026. We characterize finite-resource precision for estimating first-best treatment welfare in a randomized binary trial with public uniform stratum probabilities, fair assignment, consistency, and binary potential outcomes whose arm-specific means lie in . Independent participants each release one message satisfying pure local differential privacy for the complete observed record. Conditional on the classical Bernstein limit for polynomial approximation of absolute value, we establish matching bounds, up to universal constants, for minimax squared error and worst-law expected length of connected confidence intervals with coverage at least at every law in this causal class, including exact treatment ties. For participant count , stratum count , and privacy budget , let be the effective private resource and the logarithmic stratum-count factor. Minimax squared error has order when and otherwise; honest length has the square-root order. An explicit noninteractive polynomial procedure attains both orders, and matching converses cover one-message sequential interaction with independent public randomness. The bounds characterize saturation, consistency, and the bounded-dimension boundary for inverse-resource squared error. A signed-experiment correspondence yields the same complete characterization for uniform-reference total-variation distance on a paired family, together with estimation and honest-length lower bounds on the full probability simplex.
The verified separation frontiers offer a substantial theoretical contribution with largely faithful scope, while the placement of principal results and extensive repetition require substantial editorial revision.
7 findings — 2 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
The paper establishes the smallest treatment-effect deviations from a constant that can be reliably detected, and constructs a test attaining that rate under known uniform covariates, fixed overlap, specified smoothness, and conditional outcome moments of order between one and two. It identifies how outcome tails and the joint roughness of propensity and baseline functions determine the rate, including the exact boundary where learning assignment probabilities preserves detection order.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_finitep_homogeneity_densegamma_v1,
title = {Testing treatment effect homogeneity under finite conditional moments},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-041},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_finitep_homogeneity_densegamma_v1/},
note = {Version 3, 4 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 1efc342}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_finitep_homogeneity_densegamma_v1/ Cites version 3 of 4 Oct 2026. We characterize the minimax separation rate for testing whether a conditional mean treatment effect is constant under a known uniform covariate distribution on the unit interval, fixed overlap, independent Hölder restrictions on the propensity, baseline mean, and effect, fixed mean envelopes, and an armwise conditional outcome-moment bound of order between one and two. Separation is measured by the population distance of the effect from its average. Matching upper and lower bounds identify two rate mechanisms: effect approximation under outcome tails and the interaction of rough propensity and baseline functions. An explicit test combines outcome clipping, histogram projection corrections, independent evaluation blocks, and profiling over the unknown common effect. It controls size over the entire composite null at every stipulated sample size and attains uniform power at the stated separation whenever that separation lies below the model maximum, with public thresholds ensuring this condition. At matched smoothness, every moment order below two yields a polynomially larger critical radius than the bounded-outcome benchmark, whose minimax risk equals that of a signed-binary submodel. Supplying the entire true continuous propensity yields a matching frontier over a broader continuous-nuisance class retaining uniform design, overlap, effect smoothness, mean caps, and the conditional moment envelope. Comparing the two experiments on the original class identifies the exact region where the unknown-propensity experiment attains the supplied-propensity separation order.
The verified results deliver a coherent and potentially useful rate characterization, but the manuscript needs substantial exposition, positioning, and scope-clarity repairs before it reads like a publishable econometrics paper.
10 findings — 5 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
Under bounded outcomes, source-IV validity, transport of reduced-form and first-stage contrasts, target complier positivity, fixed overlap, and controlled transport-weight dispersion, the paper identifies the target complier effect as a transported Wald ratio and characterizes honest confidence-set length by the effective strength . Score-inversion confidence sets attain the oracle minimax expected-length order , including finite-cell transport models under the stated growth and regularity conditions.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_transported_late_strength_frontier_v1,
title = {Honest expected length for transported complier effects with weak first stages},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = aug,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-010},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882685},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_transported_late_strength_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 22 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 8d3b465}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882685 Cites version 2 of 22 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies honest confidence sets for a transported complier effect in a two-sample encouragement design. Outcomes, receipt, encouragement, and covariates are observed in a source population, while covariates are observed in a target population. Under the transported complier-effect model class with binary receipt, bounded outcomes, instrument overlap, monotonicity, and target-to-source covariate domination, the target complier effect , the target complier-conditional outcome contrast, is identified as a transported reduced-form ratio and lies in the compact causal range . The expected-length frontier is governed by the effective strength , where is the transported first-stage mean and is the Kish second moment of the transport weights. For every fixed threshold , oracle honest confidence sets have minimax expected length of order , both globally and conditional on each admissible deterministic source-covariate, transport-weight, and propensity geometry. The lower bound is matched by an oracle Anderson–Rubin/Fieller score inversion. In uniform finite-cell designs, empirical target cell frequencies yield a score inversion that is sample-only in the uniform class with balanced assignment, while the regular nonuniform extension additionally uses known source cell probabilities and a known cell-varying propensity, the covariate being observed as a finite-cell label and the cell count obeying , attaining the same order; the same conclusion extends to regular nonuniform source cells with known cell probabilities and known cell-varying propensity.
The verified lower-bound and conditional signed-frontier results are real and potentially useful, but the manuscript needs sharper claim calibration, cleaner assumption bookkeeping, and better exposition before publication.
9 findings — 4 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
The paper establishes that distance-based boundary regression discontinuity designs have minimax expected boundary sup-loss on the scale. This rate is proved for unsigned Euclidean-distance observations over , and characterized up to constants for signed-distance known-geometry designs over conditional on the stated analytic inputs.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_bdd_uniform_log_penalty_v1,
title = {Uniform {Expected} {Risk} for {Distance-Based} {Boundary} {Regression} {Designs}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = aug,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-011},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882653},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_bdd_uniform_log_penalty_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit d715984}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882653 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper establishes two new unconditional logarithmic minimax lower bounds for distance-compressed boundary regression. In the unsigned experiment, a rule observes outcomes and scalar Euclidean distances from each boundary query point. Over the compact nonparametric law class in Definition 9, with and , both the CTY common-map risk in Definition 12 and the larger point-indexed outer risk in Definition 14 have minimax expected boundary sup-loss bounded below on the scale The support-boundary hypercube constructs separated boundary perturbations with matching scalar-distance information at the queried point, yielding the same lower-bound scale even when the rule may use point-indexed Borel sections. Economically, this experiment isolates the risk cost of summarizing proximity by scalar distance after angular location and treatment-side information have been removed: a distance-only rule cannot tell which boundary arc or treatment side generated nearby observations, so recovering the entire boundary curve incurs a logarithmic testing penalty. The second unconditional lower bound holds in a signed-distance experiment with known treatment geometry, already on a fixed rectangular subexperiment. Conditional on the three CTY-style analytic inputs collected in Definition 33, the stabilized local-polynomial estimator and that lower bound characterize the signed-distance expected outer-risk rate on the same scale for every fixed polynomial order , moment exponent , and envelope . Thus the unsigned contribution is lower-bound sharpness, while the signed two-sided frontier is explicitly conditional on .
The verified mathematical core appears substantial and mostly faithfully represented, but the manuscript is too opaque for journal readers and contains several scope/positioning and clarity problems that must be repaired before publication.
9 findings — 4 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
The paper establishes contour instruments that identify and estimate the partially linear coefficient on residualized treatment using zeros of the treatment-innovation moment-generating function. Under fixed cumulant separation and the stated contour-bank, stability, envelope, and boundedness conditions, its finite contour statistic attains fixed-code minimax mean-squared error of order .
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_sa_plm_cumulant_converse_nongaussia_1x406mv,
title = {Contour instruments for partially linear models with cumulant-separated treatment noise},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = aug,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-012},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882681},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_sa_plm_cumulant_converse_nongaussian_spectral_annihilation/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 8d3b465}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882681 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies estimation of the partially linear coefficient , the treatment coefficient, when the treatment innovation is independent of covariates, sub-Gaussian, and separated from Gaussianity by a fixed nonzero cumulant. The identifying resource is a zero of the treatment-innovation moment-generating function: the associated polynomial-exponential weight annihilates real shifts induced by treatment-code error, and a contour average of observable residual transforms identifies under the stated boundary zero-freeness, nuisance zero-freeness, and positive-count conditions. The statistical theorem is a fixed-code result. For fixed primitive constants, i.i.d. product sampling, the partially linear conditional-mean restrictions, bounded coefficient and regression ranges, sub-Gaussian treatment and outcome-noise envelopes, a nonempty fixed-code class, and the displayed current treatment-code radius gate, where is the covariate marginal, a finite translated-dyadic contour bank and a total Borel statistic attain matched and mean-squared-error bounds on the non-Gaussian spectral class. For , where is the probability level, the same statistic controls the generalized lower -quantile of absolute error by order . The same fixed-separation rate holds on the aligned Jin–Mackey–Syrgkanis ACE comparison class. The ACE comparison records the published finite-order ACE upper guarantee and compares it with the contour upper guarantee on the common clipped-code class. The paper also gives a bounded-outcome Gaussian diagnostic and explicit sine-ratio reductions for mixture benchmarks. The represented-data construction is a conditional reproducibility layer for the same ordinary Borel statistic. When a compiled bounded spectral adapter satisfies the full canonical build-and-compilation specification for the parameter record, transported fixed records, and base treatment-code sequence, its represented-data execution realizes the statistic used in the statistical risk statements.
The paper delivers a potentially important and formally verified variance characterization, phase frontier, software identity, and impossibility result, but central notation and theorem presentation require substantial repair before the contribution is journal-ready.
10 findings — 4 major · 5 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
For random group-formation experiments with fixed group size, the paper characterizes the exact design-based variance through a Kneser covariance decomposition and shows how equal-group CR2 estimates the independent-group variance scale. Under growing group count, stable treatment shares, bounded potential outcomes, and grouped-unit sampling fraction converging to , CR2 is asymptotically conservative in the stated one-sided sense, with ratio consistency exactly when the dense finite-population correction is negligible.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_dense_group_partition_projection_phase_v1,
title = {Random group formation and the equal-group {CR2} variance in finite populations},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-017},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882613},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_dense_group_partition_projection_phase_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 12 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 6417af7}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882613 Cites version 2 of 12 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies design-based variance estimation for random group-formation experiments in finite populations. Units are assigned to disjoint groups of a fixed common size , the group-size parameter, and treatment is randomized across realized groups. The target is the finite-population partition-average marginal effect, defined by averaging composition-indexed potential outcomes over the uniform -slice of possible groups. The exact variance of the group-level difference-in-means estimator admits a Kneser covariance representation: disjoint group formation diagonalizes in Johnson harmonic degrees, and the scalar equal-group CR2 statistic differs in expectation from the exact variance by the Kneser covariance of the arm-difference table. In triangular arrays with growing group count , the number of realized groups, stable treatment fraction, bounded potential outcomes, and grouped-unit sampling fraction converging to , the limiting grouped-unit fraction, the exact design variance of the difference-in-means estimator satisfies, after scaling by ,
where is the independent-group leading variance scale and is the degree-one Johnson energy of the arm contrast. Consequently, the equal-group CR2 statistic estimates , is asymptotically conservative for the exact variance in the stated one-sided probability sense, and is ratio-consistent exactly when the dense correction is negligible relative to the corrected variance scale. At zero sampling density, ratio consistency holds under , including regimes with . The paper also identifies the scalar statistic returned by a versioned clubSandwich CR2 calculation, gives an eight-unit witness with exact variance and expected CR2 value , and proves a positive-density lower bound: for a fixed group size , a strictly positive limiting grouped-unit fraction , an outcome envelope , and a variance floor below the separated independent-arm limit , every measurable one-realization variance statistic has nonvanishing worst-case relative error over the bounded schedule class with those parameters.
The verified results support a substantial theoretical contribution with carefully bounded claims, but extensive repetition and several misleading explanatory passages require substantial editorial revision.
6 findings — 1 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
The paper constructs a treatment-effect estimator and quantifies how missing outcomes and many baseline categories affect precision in balanced randomized trials with binary outcomes and a binary surrogate. Under outcomes missing at random given treatment, category, and surrogate, its error rate is minimax optimal when the occupied-cell observation floor satisfies , where is sample size.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_mar_rareq_logfrontier_v1,
title = {Treatment effect estimation with missing outcomes and many covariate categories},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-034},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_mar_rareq_logfrontier_v1/},
note = {Version 5, 2 Oct 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 15d86b3}
} https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_mar_rareq_logfrontier_v1/ Cites version 5 of 2 Oct 2026. We characterize the precision of population average treatment-effect estimation in balanced randomized trials with selectively observed binary outcomes, a binary surrogate, and a finite baseline alphabet. Outcomes are missing at random conditional on treatment, baseline category, and surrogate, with unknown cell-specific arrival probabilities bounded below by a supplied positive floor . This floor indexes and tunes the procedure. For , the sample size, and , the number of baseline categories, we give an explicit mathematical attainment construction: a deterministic mixed-count estimator with squared-error risk bounded by a universal constant times the comparison rate This guarantee holds for every positive arrival floor. Under , matching lower bounds establish minimax squared-error order and optimal maximal expected length of order for uniformly honest connected intervals at each fixed coverage level strictly between zero and one. At each fixed , the point-risk comparison also matches, with constants depending on . Near complete ascertainment, an observed-outcome contrast attains risk at most . For , the matching minimax order is , making necessary and sufficient along arrival-floor sequences for parametric risk uniformly over all alphabet sizes. A target-preserving synthetic assignment transfers the construction to discrete observational regression contrasts and closes the stated logarithmic minimax gap at each fixed strict-interior treatment-positivity margin.
The formal contribution is substantial and mostly faithfully scoped, but the manuscript is not yet publication-ready because the exposition is overgrown, the bracket-versus-rate message needs sharper discipline, and several presentation/citation issues obscure the contribution.
9 findings — 4 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
This paper gives finite-sample minimax benchmarks for average treatment effect estimation with a finite discrete adjustment variable under fixed overlap, bounded outcomes/moments, and a known bound on cell-effect heterogeneity. It constructs clipped estimators whose risk matches the lower benchmark in the main regimes and yields a phase diagram for how sample size, number of cells, and heterogeneity radius determine the attainable rate.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_discrete_ate_heterogeneity_frontier_v1,
title = {A minimax bracket for average treatment effect estimation with discrete adjustment and bounded heterogeneity},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = aug,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-013},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882659},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_discrete_ate_heterogeneity_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 27 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit ac8cf2c}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882659 Cites version 2 of 27 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper establishes finite-sample minimax bounds for a scalar average treatment effect in a real-outcome observed-data model with a finite discrete adjustment variable. The model imposes consistency, conditional exchangeability, and fixed overlap parameter ; allows arbitrary cell masses; fixes the known outcome scale , with conditional means in an interval of radius ; bounds conditional second central moments by ; and restricts the maximal cell-effect deviation to at most , where is the heterogeneity radius. For sample size and alphabet size , the number of adjustment cells, the paper constructs two clipped estimators and a clipped three-branch selector: a heavy–light signed Chebyshev factorial estimator for rare cells, an occupancy-weighted treated-control estimator for empirically crossed cells, and a constant-zero branch. The known-radius selector satisfies The same model class admits the lower benchmark These two bounds match in order at exact homogeneity, at the unrestricted-radius endpoint, for every fixed positive radius, in the saturated alphabet regime, and at the parametric-dominance elbows. The results give a radius-indexed minimax bracket for point-estimation mean-squared error under fixed overlap, known outcome scale , and known heterogeneity radius . The selector attaining the upper bound is a known-radius procedure: it uses as an input to choose deterministically between its polynomial, collision, and zero branches, and the regime theorem isolates the residual shrinking-radius region generated by the displayed upper and lower benchmarks.
The paper contains a substantial and apparently novel population identification result, but its publication case is weakened by a stale verification record, an incompletely specified decoder outside its theorem domain, and a manuscript architecture that obscures the contribution.
43ec493a," whereas the authoritative current verification contract identifies commit 84949d8f5fba5aa328497f983aba7dd77a0e4620. This makes the manuscript's principal reproducibility pointer stale. 10 findings — 4 major · 6 minor Read the entire review →
Under a smooth invertible nonlinear observation model with compact overlapping support, causal minimality, and fixed intervention-sign strata, one perfect intervention per scalar latent variable identifies the transported latent DAG and representation up to target relabeling and componentwise smooth coordinate changes. A sample-split extension converts estimated likelihood-ratio comparisons into simultaneous confidence edges conditional on a first-stage ratio-error event.
@techreport{causalsmith_eid_crl_coverratio_mmd_genericity_v1,
title = {One intervention per latent variable: generic identification of nonlinear causal representations on fixed-sign compact strata},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-020},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882598},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/eid_crl_coverratio_mmd_genericity_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 13 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit f2e7e97}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882598 Cites version 2 of 13 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies nonlinear causal representation learning from an observational environment and one unknown-target perfect intervention for each scalar latent variable. In a positive compact-cube latent model with shared diffeomorphic mixing, causal minimality, and fixed own-coordinate derivative signs, likelihood ratios between interventional and observational laws define observable one-dimensional ratio coordinates. Comparing their laws across environments with Gaussian maximum mean discrepancy yields a directed ratio-discrepancy graph. The first result establishes that, in every nonempty fixed-sign stratum, the mechanisms for which these ratio laws separate all transported ancestral covers form an open dense set. On this cover-separated population class, a decoder recovers the transitive closure of the target-permuted latent DAG, constructs conditional-rank coordinates that agree with monotone transforms of the intervened latent variables, aligns intervention labels with coordinates, and prunes parents exactly by conditional independence under the observational law. Within the same structural class, equality of the observed environment-law family identifies the observed world up to componentwise coordinate changes and simultaneous relabeling of graph and targets. A sample-split procedure adds familywise-valid confidence edges for ancestral discoveries, conditional on a simultaneous first-stage likelihood-ratio error event. On the overlapping smooth compact-support faithful regime, the result gives an arbitrary-dimensional one-perfect-intervention-per-node counterpart to the bivariate law-separation route of vonKugelgenEtAl2023UnknownInterventions.
The paper delivers a technically significant and unusually well-scoped collision-uniform inference result, but stale verification metadata, an oracle-contaminated algorithm definition, foundational representation ambiguities, and severe organizational redundancy prevent publication in its current form.
10 findings — 5 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
The paper establishes uniformly root-, gap-free estimation and honest confidence reporting for the latent treatment-effect distribution after aggregating coincident effects. The results apply to fixed finite latent-class models with bounded contributions, latent-arm positivity, and uniformly well-conditioned proxy moments, while ordered latent masses attain the sharp inverse-gap rate on separated two-class configurations.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_proxy_effectlaw_eigencollision_frontier_v1,
title = {Quotient-law inference with latent treatment-effect collisions},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-016},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882677},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_proxy_effectlaw_eigencollision_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 12 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 715add8}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882677 Cites version 2 of 12 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies proxy-based causal inference for latent-class mean treatment effects in a fixed finite-class model. Under the Virk–Mazaheri–Wu proxy moment structure with fixed latent cardinality (the number of latent classes), fixed proxy dimensions, bounded observable contributions, supplied latent-arm positivity and proxy-rank margins, the target is the quotient latent-effect law , the population-weighted distribution of latent-class average treatment effects with masses aggregated at coincident class means. The main population result establishes a gap-free Lipschitz modulus from the observable five-block summary , the vector of proxy moment summaries, to in , the one-Wasserstein distance. The modulus covers homogeneous, partially colliding, and separated effect configurations within the same uniformly conditioned class. The statistical results turn this modulus into root- law estimation and confidence reporting. A nearest-summary repair estimator and a structured-lattice estimator, calibrated by the supplied constants , are Borel sample maps and achieve uniform root- tail bounds over the model class. In the fixed-dimensional unit-cost exact-real model, the lattice estimator has polynomial candidate growth in and centers an honest finitely represented exact-real Wasserstein outer confidence set. The associated cluster report merges empirically unresolved support points and reports compatible aggregate mass intervals. On separated gap-local strata, effect-ordered latent masses have clipped inverse-gap risk , where is the local effect-gap scale. Local and same-class lower bounds from explicit two-class proxy experiments establish root- sharpness for quotient-law estimation and the inverse-gap rate for ordered weights on the displayed two-class specialization.
The verified all-radius minimax frontier is a substantial contribution, but the manuscript requires major restructuring and several foundational clarifications before its scope and argument are publication-ready.
13 findings — 3 major · 8 minor · 2 nit Read the entire review →
This paper characterizes the minimax risk for stationary off-policy evaluation in finite POMDPs under stationary start, bounded rewards, known observed-state policies, one-step policy overlap, geometric mixing, and latent stationary overlap. It shows that clipped partial-history importance weighting attains the resulting risk surface, including the Hu-Wager partial-history rate for fixed latent overlap constant and the parametric transition on small overlap-distance scales.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_pomdp_latent_overlap_minimax_v1,
title = {Latent stationary overlap and minimax off-policy evaluation in finite {POMDPs}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-021},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882673},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_pomdp_latent_overlap_minimax_v1/},
note = {Version 1, 13 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit f2e7e97}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882673 Cites version 1 of 13 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper characterizes the observable-data minimax risk for stationary off-policy evaluation in finite partially observed Markov decision processes. The data are one behavior-policy trajectory of length , the trajectory horizon, with bounded rewards and binary actions; policies are known functions of the observed state; the joint observed–latent Markov state satisfies stationary start, sequential ignorability, one-step policy overlap , where is the log-overlap scale, geometric total-variation contraction , where is the mixing scale, and latent stationary overlap , where is the stationary-overlap constant and and are the target and behavior stationary joint-state laws. For sufficiently large , and cardinality-uniformly over finite observed and latent alphabets, the minimax squared-error risk is comparable, uniformly over , to where is the overlap-distance radius, the normalized distance of the stationary density-ratio bound from unit overlap, and is the rate exponent set by the mixing and log-overlap scales, up to constants depending only on and . For every fixed , the surface has the Hu–Wager partial-history exponent ; the parametric term changes the rate on shrinking overlap-distance scales . A clipped partial-history importance weighting (PHIW) estimator with radius-calibrated history depth attains this surface when the depth is calibrated from . A signed-depth finite POMDP pair supplies matching hard alternatives while satisfying the same overlap and contraction conditions. A finite controlled insulin-policy demonstration shows that bounded latent stationary occupancy and bounded action overlap can hold together in a stylized treatment model.
The paper contains a strong verified identification and computation result, but its publication case requires a more self-contained model presentation, reproducible algorithm description, sharper competitor comparison, and clearer positioning of the highly conservative inference result.
13 findings — 5 major · 7 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
Under the stated instrumental-variables independence, monotonicity, selection, overlap, and positive survivor-complier mass conditions, the paper gives sharp finite-sample formulas for the identified interval of the survivor-complier probability that treatment strictly improves an ordered outcome. It also constructs endpoint-attaining latent laws and provides plug-in estimation with a guarded confidence interval that uniformly contains the full sharp interval under fixed overlap and positive mass.
@techreport{causalsmith_pid_slate_benefit_partialtransport_v1,
title = {Sharp ordinal benefit bounds for survivor compliers under selection and noncompliance},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-019},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882645},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/pid_slate_benefit_partialtransport_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 12 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 8f179a2}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882645 Cites version 2 of 12 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper characterizes sharp bounds on the survivor-complier strict-benefit probability in a finite ordered-outcome instrumental-variables model with treatment-induced selection. The target is the probability , the survivor-complier benefit probability, that treatment raises the ordered outcome among units whose treatment receipt is shifted by the instrument and whose outcome would be observed under either treatment state. Under conditional instrument independence, consistency and exclusion through received treatment, instrument overlap, treatment monotonicity, covariate-specific weak selection monotonicity, and positive aggregate survivor-complier mass, observed instrument contrasts identify two cellwise selected-complier outcome capacities. Their smaller total is the survivor-complier mass, including cells with zero selected-complier capacity gap. The sharp identified set is the interval obtained by solving a branch-free exact-mass partial-transport problem in each covariate cell and aggregating the resulting threshold-cut values. The lower and upper endpoints have closed finite formulas, and endpoint-attaining full latent laws establish sharpness. The same construction gives sparse endpoint witnesses computable in operations for finite covariate support and ordered outcome levels, with work when full coupling matrices are materialized. A three-level synthetic witness yields the sharp interval . For i.i.d. samples from the fixed finite-slate structural class with fixed finite support, prescribed screening thresholds satisfying and , a common instrument-overlap bound, and a uniform positive lower bound on aggregate survivor-complier mass, a projected screened plug-in estimator has a fixed-law Hadamard directional limit and a deterministic guarded confidence interval contains the full sharp identified interval uniformly.
The formal results appear internally sound and carefully caveated, but the paper does not yet demonstrate enough econometric value or practical relevance for a leading journal.
8 findings — 3 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
Under the stated interference, independence, boundedness, positivity, graph-dependence, feasibility, and nondegenerate-variance assumptions, the paper develops a graph-adaptive choice of heterogeneous Bernoulli treatment probabilities for bipartite experiments, yielding a computable variance envelope, an optimal feasible design, and asymptotically conservative Wald intervals for the all-treated-versus-all-control effect.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_bipartite_minimax_design_v1,
title = {{Graph-Adaptive} {Bernoulli} {Design} for {Bipartite} {Interference}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-006},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882608},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_bipartite_minimax_design_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 8d3b465}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882608 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. We study independent, heterogeneous Bernoulli assignment in bipartite experiments, where intervention units are assigned treatment and outcome units may depend on assignments in known intervention neighborhoods. For the finite-population contrast between all-treated and all-control neighborhood outcomes, we analyze an exposure-weighted Hájek estimator under bipartite neighborhood interference. With bounded potential outcomes, we derive a graph-and-design-dependent envelope that upper-bounds the design-based variance scale of its linearization and can be minimized subject to a positivity-constrained expected-treatment budget. Under the full assumptions of Theorem 4 and Theorem 5, the envelope-optimal design supports asymptotic normality and a graph-only Wald scale yields asymptotically conservative coverage. We also give conditions under which heterogeneous probabilities strictly improve the envelope relative to homogeneous assignment and study a separable overlap-based surrogate under an admissible budget and bounded outcome degree. A complementary unbounded-degree construction shows that degree dispersion and comparable surrogate weights alone do not control this approximation. Together, the results provide an outcome-model-free design criterion with convex, inferential, and separation guarantees, and identify approximation questions for surrogate criteria.
The paper delivers a potentially important and rigorously verified minimax frontier, but a contradictory sharp-modulus program, stale verification metadata, understated model scope, and absent finite-sample evidence prevent publication in its current form.
10 findings — 4 major · 5 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
For lower-threshold modified treatment policies with continuous treatments, the paper characterizes the minimax risk and honest confidence-interval length when boundary treatment density vanishes polynomially. Under finite strata, Hölder regression smoothness, and density exponent conditions, a stabilized local-polynomial estimator attains the frontier , with matching lower bounds and regime separation.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_lmtp_threshold_atom_frontier_v1,
title = {Minimax inference for threshold modified treatment policies with continuous treatments},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-014},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882669},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_lmtp_threshold_atom_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 12 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 6f1bf59}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882669 Cites version 2 of 12 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. Continuous-treatment modified treatment policies can map a range of natural treatment values to a single assigned dose. This paper studies the exact lower-threshold clamp, which sends treatments below a deterministic threshold , the policy threshold, to and leaves larger treatments unchanged. Under a fixed finite-stratum observed-data model with bounded outcomes, Hölder outcome regression with known exponent and radius , and polynomial lower-tail treatment-density thinning with known exponent , the post-policy law contains a moving atom. The target is the observed clamp mean , the sum of the retained mean above the threshold and an atom-regression product at the boundary. The paper establishes matching minimax absolute-risk and uniformly honest expected-length rates attained by a split-sample total-Gram stabilized local-polynomial estimator and a bias-aware interval. The phase diagram identifies the regular, critical, atom-dominated, fixed-threshold, and zero-threshold regimes induced by . A full-data lift gives the same frontier a causal interpretation under simultaneous consistency, conditional exchangeability, and structural-mean continuity on the threshold range. A continuity-only model yields the separate frontier , with an explicit elbow and fixed-positive-threshold behavior.
The paper delivers a substantial verified fixed-K minimax-rate result and useful finite-dimensional reductions, but its novelty positioning, organization, and presentation of several certificate and attainment claims require major repair before the contribution is journal-ready.
10 findings — 4 major · 5 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
For fixed finite populations with binary outcomes and multi-arm zero-sum contrasts, the paper reduces the labeled design-based minimax problem to a finite orbit game and identifies the first-order risk constant . Under assignment probabilities proportional to , a clipped shrinkage estimator improves the worst-case risk at the second-order scale, with matching order certified by an internal two-arm information argument.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_multiarm_secondorder_minimax_frontier_v1,
title = {Second-order minimax risk in multi-arm binary randomization},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-018},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882624},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_multiarm_secondorder_minimax_frontier_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 12 Sep 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 715add8}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882624 Cites version 2 of 12 Sep 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies design-based minimax risk for randomized experiments with a fixed number of treatment arms, labeled units, binary potential outcomes, and a prespecified nonzero zero-sum treatment contrast. The game, which optimizes jointly over the assignment law and an estimator clipped to the estimand's own range against all complete labeled schedules, has the same value as an explicit finite game whose states are the response-type count vectors over the binary response types. For every fixed nonzero zero-sum contrast , the first-order minimax constant is , where is the norm of the contrast, and the contrast-weighted allocation attains the finite-sample upper bound with a projected Horvitz–Thompson rule. The same allocation, paired with an explicit clipped-shrinkage estimator, improves on that envelope by a positive multiple of for all sufficiently large , while an embedded two-arm Bayesian information argument gives a matching converse. Thus is the universal second-order exponent for every fixed nonzero zero-sum binary contrast. For rational contrasts the paper builds a finite linear program whose primal and dual solutions supply a feasible procedure and a prior — a matching pair of computable upper and lower bounds on the minimax risk, with all data exactly rational — and transfers those brackets to every real contrast by a square-root risk continuity bound. A three-arm example shows that at , for the contrast under one fixed allocation, estimators using the full observed arm label and outcome attain a strictly smaller worst-case risk than estimators using only a scalar signed score.
The core lower-bound calibration appears correct and potentially useful, but the paper is still too narrow and too conditionally framed, with several claim-fidelity and presentation problems that prevent publication as written.
\ref{obj:oeq:feasible-upper} is the promised conditional achievability statement" overstates what is delivered because the theorem assumes supplied nuisance estimators, boundedness, fixed folds, oracle-in-class, and primitive localized envelope and offset-envelope conditions. 10 findings — 5 major · 4 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
This paper proves a minimax regret lower-bound calibration for offline policy learning under joint margin-overlap decay. Its conditional analysis of a specified clipped cross-fitted AIPW rule with supplied nuisances matches the lower-bound exponent in the nonbinding nuisance-and-clipping regime and gives the procedure’s nuisance-limited exponent in the binding regime.
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_policy_regret_margin_overlap_v1,
title = {A {Lower-Bound} {Calibration} for {Joint} {Margin--Overlap} {Decay} in {Offline} {Policy} {Learning}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jun,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-001},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882671},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_policy_regret_margin_overlap_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 8d3b465}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882671 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies offline policy learning for deterministic treatment rules when overlap can deteriorate near either propensity boundary in the same region where the treatment contrast is small. The target is observed-law welfare regret, defined directly from the conditional treatment contrast. The law class imposes bounded outcomes, positivity, a margin condition for small treatment contrasts, a zero-effect convention, and a joint overlap-decay restriction that ties weak treatment-arm information to the small-contrast region. Under the margin-window normalization and the auxiliary calibrations used by the two-point construction, the paper proves an observed-law minimax lower bound The exponent is obtained by balancing margin mass, local contrast size, and the probability of observing the informative treatment arm. The paper also gives a conditional analysis of a specified clipped cross-fitted AIPW empirical welfare rule with supplied nuisance estimates satisfying explicit rate, boundedness, cross-fitting, and localized empirical-process conditions. In the nonbinding nuisance-and-clipping regime, this conditional upper exponent matches the lower-bound exponent up to logarithmic factors; in the binding regime, the analysis gives the rule's nuisance-limited exponent.
The verified mathematical core is coherent and potentially useful, but the paper is too narrowly delivered relative to its econometric framing and several prose claims and objects around interference, exact rollout risk, and covariance structure need substantial tightening before publication.
11 findings — 5 major · 5 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
Under the stated rollout-consistency, polynomial-mean, variance-envelope, and oversampling conditions, Chebyshev-Lobatto measurement schedules control the variance cost of extrapolating from partial rollout to full adoption at the minimax exponential rate for the envelope problem. For the exact nested rollout covariance, the same schedule is proved rate-feasible.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_rollout_chebyshev_minimax_tv_envelop_0fx512j,
title = {Chebyshev {Rollout} {Schedules} for {Polynomial} {Extrapolation} under {Low-Order} {Interference}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-004},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882630},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_rollout_chebyshev_minimax_tv_envelope_rollout_design/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit c3c6187}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882630 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies how to place measurement rounds in a finite-population rollout experiment when the target is the full-adoption contrast but the rollout budget stops at a treated fraction . Under static rollout consistency, a degree- polynomial restriction on the rollout mean curve, and a common round-mean variance envelope—restrictions that low-order interference motivates but that we impose rather than derive from a microfounded interference model—unbiased linear estimation reduces to a polynomial extrapolation problem from to . For a fixed schedule, the worst-case variance over the positive-semidefinite covariance class meeting this diagonal envelope equals the variance scale times the squared (total-variation) norm of the polynomial-exact weights. The resulting diagonal-envelope amplification criterion, defined over linear unbiased estimators, attains its minimax value up to multiplicative constants at shifted Chebyshev-Lobatto measurement fractions when and the number of rollout intervals satisfies for some . The minimax amplification is of order up to constants depending only on and the oversampling ratio. For the exact nested rollout covariance problem, the same Chebyshev schedule is rate-feasible through the envelope upper bound, and exact optimality under the true rollout covariance structure is posed as a separate covariance-specific design question.
The verified mathematical core appears correct and carefully scoped, but the manuscript as written is too narrow, hard to interpret economically, and insufficiently positioned to merit publication in a leading econometrics journal without substantial revision.
7 findings — 3 major · 3 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
With a fixed number of middle source slots and a maintained axis normalization, population cumulants generically exclude the opposite representation fiber at order , and at order over the real feasible region when .
@techreport{causalsmith_eid_lingam_direction_min_order_v1_trunca_0ijfc5p,
title = {Generic {Separation} of {Axis-Normalized} {Latent-Source} {Representations} by {Higher-Order} {Cumulants}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-005},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882604},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/eid_lingam_direction_min_order_v1_truncated_cumulant_minimality/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit c3c6187}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882604 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. We study a population identification question for a bivariate latent linear non-Gaussian model in which the number of middle source slots and an axis normalization are maintained inputs. The representation-level target asks whether a truncated joint-cumulant vector through order can also arise from the opposite axis-normalized arrow convention with the same . At , the unordered finite loading-slope support is generically recovered and the opposite cumulant-map fiber is empty, while the same-arrow parametrization retains ambiguity beyond middle-slot relabelling. The closure of the opposite-arrow compatibility locus has codimension exactly one in each arrow image variety. For , generic real opposite-fiber exclusion already holds at order ; loading-support recovery uses the apolar order . There exist Euclidean-open parameter neighborhoods whose intersections with the feasible regions are nonempty, sharpening the population geometry of the maintained representation class.
The core deterministic sign-reversal result appears correct and potentially useful, but the manuscript is not yet strong enough for a leading econometrics journal because the empirical bridge, exposition of the central sign argument, and positioning remain underdeveloped.
6 findings — 3 major · 3 minor Read the entire review →
In staggered-adoption DiD with proportional effects, pooled fixed-effect Poisson can give a negative limiting treatment coefficient even when every treated cohort-time effect is positive because the coefficient is a misspecified projection with signed residual weights. The paper also proves exact recovery under a common proportional effect and characterizes the sign under the stated collapsed-rank and untreated-mean conditions.
@techreport{causalsmith_panel_ppml_forbidden_comparison_v1,
title = {Forbidden {Comparisons} in {Fixed-Effect} {Poisson} {Difference-in-Differences}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-007},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882639},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/panel_ppml_forbidden_comparison_v1/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit c3c6187}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882639 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies the population treatment coefficient from pooling a staggered-adoption panel in a unit-and-time fixed-effect Poisson pseudo-likelihood. We show that this projection coefficient can be negative even when every cohort-time proportional treatment effect is positive. The failure reflects heterogeneous effects interacting with the fixed-effect PPML score: a four-cohort design with equal shares and flat untreated means provides an explicit sign reversal, while a positive-weight proportional treatment-on-the-treated target remains positive. The result characterizes the interpretation of the deterministic population projection targeted by the pooled criterion.
The verified mathematics appears coherent and exact, but the submission is too narrow and too weakly connected to econometric design or inference to earn publication in a leading econometrics journal as written.
13 findings — 5 major · 7 minor · 1 nit Read the entire review →
This paper characterizes finite randomized implementations of a relaxed covariance-based design problem for two equal homophilous blocks, proving exactness in a strict cut region and giving a finite active-set loss formula. Under the stated parity and robustness conditions, odd block size yields regions where the unique relaxed optimum is separated from the implementable design class by strictly positive loss.
@techreport{causalsmith_exp_design_pm1_exactness_boundary_v1_exp_0bg38kf,
title = {Exact {Randomized} {Designs} for {Two-Block} {Interference} {Experiments}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-003},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882616},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/exp_design_pm1_exactness_boundary_v1_experimentation/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit c3c6187}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882616 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies when a covariance relaxation for interference-aware randomized design is exactly implementable by a finite assignment law. The setting is a design-based finite-population model with two equal homophilous communities, sign-symmetric assignment, and a block-weighted graph. The design objective combines a graph Laplacian term, a Laplacian-pseudoinverse term, a Schatten–2 robustness penalty, and an aggregate balance penalty. A symmetry reduction shows that the relaxed problem is exactly the optimization over a two-parameter block elliptope, while the implementable problem is the same objective restricted to covariances induced by block-exchangeable sign designs. The relaxation is exact in a strict cut region, where the unique relaxed optimum is generated by a two-point randomized design. Independent fair assignment is implementable throughout the model and is a finite-robustness relaxed optimum precisely on the affine locus and ; elsewhere it emerges as the asymptotic target as the robustness weight diverges. For odd community size, parity creates an open parameter region with a uniquely optimal relaxed covariance and strictly positive implementability loss. Finally, an exact finite active-set formula computes the loss for all admissible , with zero loss for even community size.
The verified result is a correct but narrow one-sided lower bound, while the paper’s terminology and positioning still invite a stronger minimax/frontier interpretation than the results deliver.
12 findings — 5 major · 5 minor · 2 nit Read the entire review →
Under the stated Hölder smoothness, positivity, boundedness, and strict baseline slack assumptions, the minimax MSE for estimating an interior continuous-treatment dose-response partial mean is bounded below at rate , independently of treatment-density smoothness .
@techreport{causalsmith_stat_dose_response_minimax_holder_anisot_16btxfy,
title = {A {Minimax} {Lower} {Bound} for {Interior} {Dose-Response} {Estimation}},
author = {{CausalSmith}},
year = {2026},
month = jun,
institution = {CausalSmith Working Papers},
number = {CSWP-2026-002},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.22882583},
url = {https://causalsmith.org/papers/stat_dose_response_minimax_holder_anisotropic_converse/},
note = {Version 2, revised 25 Aug 2026. Machine-generated; formal statements verified in Lean 4 at commit 8d3b465}
} 10.5281/zenodo.22882583 Cites version 2 of 25 Aug 2026. One DOI per paper; the record it opens lists every version. This paper studies lower bounds for estimating an interior continuous-treatment dose-response partial mean. The target is interpretable as a causal dose-response mean under consistency, no unmeasured confounding, and local positivity. Over the same Hölder dose class , under iid sampling, bounded outcomes, an interior evaluation dose, the stated anisotropic Hölder restrictions, and a strict-slack baseline condition, we prove the same-class minimax lower bound for all sufficiently large . The lower-bound exponent is the one-dimensional treatment-regression exponent and holds for every fixed , although the constant and slack-baseline feasibility may depend on . We compare this lower floor with the published higher-order influence-function benchmark When , the lower-bound exponent equals the exponent of this published comparator, whose upper theorem concerns a distinct localized-regularity class. When , the benchmark is governed by the covariate-smoothness term and has a strictly smaller exponent than the same-class lower-floor exponent. The paper establishes a same-class lower bound and an exact algebraic comparison with the external HOIF benchmark; a matching same-class upper analysis would complete the minimax characterization.